Skip to main content

Tender is the sight

The diamond industry is grappling with an issue that has been looming over everyone's heads for some years.  Moti Ganz, president of the International Diamond Manufacturers Association, just released a statement in which he claims that the rising number of tenders of rough endangers the business.  He says that without some base of established sights, where manufacturers can rely on supply, companies will have increasing difficulty sustaining factory operations, never mind invest in new factories.  He does concede that some companies failed when they lost their sights in the past number of years, but he feels that the problems inherent in tenders are worse.

Perhaps.  But there are some hard facts--and reasonable speculations--that counter his position.  The producers see the realities of the working market.  Boxes are flipped immediately for profits.  Other goods pass through many hands at times before being converted.  And major firms are increasingly dominating supplies of rough, sometimes heavily backed by banks.  Moreover, supply is continuing to fall below demand, even in these strange economic times, with the outlook being the same or worse.  Mines are playing out, and new, large sources are nowhere to be seen, even with Zimbabwe included.  Miners now feel, undoubtedly, that what is in the ground will only accrue in value, so extraction is deliberately constrained.  Add to all that the gradual leveling of the playing field, as De Beers mines decline in output.

What we have is the conditions of a "normal", competitive business environment.  One in which the big players, the miners especially, seek profit, pricing power, and competitive edge.  This is not the environment in which the industry grew and thrived in the days of De Beers dominance, the conditions that Ganz prefers in view of the highly fragmented nature of the diamond industry. 

His position does reflect some real concerns within the business.  For example, companies that deal in small goods (and therefore need to maintain large labor forces to convert the rough) are particularly concerned about continuity of supply.  The recent breathtaking surge in the price of stars illustrates the point.  Cutters, especially in India, are unwilling to open factories and pay high wages to cut these goods without knowing there will be a steady supply, especially after the many closings that occured in the downturn three years ago.  So that is a real bottleneck that has created serious shortages.

The producers, I am sure, think of their own benefit first.  A good case can be made for seeing the industry evolve into a well-structured distribution system, based on efficiency and diversity.  Obtaining rough, whether through tenders or from after-sale, would be based on economic viability, good (or specialized) market position, and downstream outlets or customers.  The present situation, as described by Ganz, is supply driven rather than demand driven, so we have companies seeking rough at "affordable" prices that feed factories the principals want to maintain.

This is going to change whether we like it or not.  Tenders give the producers the ability to maximize profits in a supply-short market.  The bottom line is that they will not want to give that up.  The only reason they have not switched wholesale to it, is their fear that the present distribution is still to frail to handle it.  But they are pushing it to change, even if it is unspoken.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The New De Beers

This past week we saw De Beers introduce Lightbox Jewelry, a full-bore, direct to consumer (DTC) retailer that will exclusively use man-made diamonds (MMDs) produced by their Element 6 division.  The concept is neatly packaged to offer a basic selection of body jewelry at moderate prices.  The DTC approach is intended to circumvent the entire traditional channels of distribution established by De Beers over the last century, in an effort to demonstrate that this is just a low-end, low-value product aimed at an under-served public.  De Beers claims that it will only benefit its existing clients by demonstrating how much more valuable "real" diamonds are. This move cam as no surprise at all to me. There are many gaps and holes in this plan, and I will try to outline them in future blog posts. To begin with, I posted three times in 2015 with my views on the subject.  Here are the links to those blog posts, as it would save me time repeating the points I made back then!

Top 10 Issues for 2015 - #5. The New Consumer

Well, the summer break is over, and we are facing a Fall season that does not seem to have much momentum.  Last time, I wrote about retailers' issues, though there is much more one can say on that subject. Now, let's think about the consumers.  Where are they?  Who are they? And will they show up this season? There is plenty of evidence that the public we have grown so accustomed to in the Consumer Age has evolved, or is evolving, into a very different public, one that has reset some values and taken a hard look what it takes to earn a dollar, and just how to spend that dollar. Maybe the best way to begin to describe this transforming mindset of the public is to make a list of what we see. Keeping up with the Jones's is dead.  Acquisition for its own sake, and to show off what we own is no more, though personal satisfaction is still there.  So that means that what you own means less than what you've done and where you've been.  (I exclude the super-rich, who

The Diamond Crisis

I was prepared to write my next big issue for 2015, number 5, but this week's news in the diamond business has diverted my attention.  Conditions have reached the boiling point, and the future is foggier than ever. Without repeating all the details that I assume most concerned people have already learned, let's look at the upshot.  (A well done update is this week's column by Edahn Golan, issued just before the latest twist.  Look at his column at http://edahngolan.com/how-sightholders-take-care-of-business-a-market-report/)  In essence, the pipeline is stuffed with diamonds.  Some sightholders have been borrowing to buy goods, but using cash flow from under-priced sales to fund investments in other, more profitable ventures.  But many of those ventures have turned sour, and there have been some bankruptcies.  Apparently, there are many dealers under great pressure, and the market is seizing up as there is fear about selling anyone.  While I do not know the details, ther